Alright I'm gonna lob this grenade into this thread and see what happens.
So Claremont's run is drawing to a close is it not from 444-474, with sales in the 70,000's I can see why they're bringing in Brubacker.
Anyway my problem with Claremonts run is that it is mostly rehashed from the 80's while it worked then but it doesn't work now.
Claremont used the Fury as the first villian in his run, but it failed it's real mission from the old Marvel Uk stories, it didn't kill anyone, you see this is why X-Men need Red Shirts like Star Trek that way someone can always die, well besides Jean. And we had that Kuroro moment
and Kurt angsting,yah.
The End of History-
Nannites-Yup
"Put to Shame"- Yup
Then there was the Viper arc, which was odd since if Bishop was immune to nannites then why was he affected by Vipers? Courtney Ross/Sat-yr-9 makes a reapperance, yah.
Nannites-Yup
Uncanny #450 introduced X-23 to their buyers, and the first meeting of Wolvy and X was retconned by Kyle and Yost in NXM #20.
Then CC hits a stride of old X-Men stories, Hellfire Club, Savage Land, Mojo, and Psylocke was resurected, in her old British body, undoing everything that had been done to here in the past decade or so.
Then there was that awful HoM arc, which was a pre-NEX, and CC's attempt at adding the Omniverse to the HoM, with such rousing characters as Roma, Saturyne, several Captain Britans, and various others, but on the
hand Nocturne was shown using her powers, some that she has currently lacked in NEX. We also had Meggan jealous of Courtney, again....you think that several years of marrige would cull the jealously, possisive isn't she? and then Meg later sacrificies herself in a meaningless death.
As we march on to Decimation we get the "End of Greys" which meaningly slaughter rivals that of NXM, of course this one was approved by x-fan
Then on to the revenge arc "Wandering Star" Which doesn't really accomplish anything besides saying that the Shi'ar are bastards and Rachel is too good to destroy them.
Then to the resurrection arc, with the insane Jamie, who's not as insane as his last apperance...
, and we get the cheap anti Phoenix knockoff the Forsaken, and Jamie and his mates were called the FOURsaken clever isn't it.
So anyway to wind up my rant let me give you the main characters/focus points of each arc.
End of History:Sage
Viper arc: Sage
Cruelest Cut: Storm,Wolverine, X-23
Chasing Hellfire:Sage,Rachel, Storm, Emma
Savage land arc:Rachel, Psylocke
HoM: Rachel, Psylocke, NEX
End of Grey-Rachel
Wandering Star-Rachel
Resurrection Arc-Psylocke
Some of y'all may have not liked Austen but at least he gave Kurt some panel time, compared to the Marvel Girl/Sage/Psylocke show that Uncanny has been since CC came along.
[Edited on 5/16/2006 by confusedelf]